Blog · Nov 19, 2026

Why a 17-Year-Old Can Be Tried as an Adult in New York: Raise the Age, Explained.

Justice for Javits

A Bronx judge just ruled that a 17-year-old charged with murder will be tried as an adult — and a lot of people are asking how that is legal if New York raised the age to 18. It is a fair question, and the answer is the part most people miss about Raise the Age.

The case is the killing of Javits Frimpong, 15, a sophomore at DreamYard Preparatory School, who was shot in the Bronx and died at a hospital. The 17-year-old is charged with murder, and also faces manslaughter and weapons charges. A grand jury is considering an indictment, and his next court appearance is scheduled for December 21.

Raise the Age raised the age — but only for most cases.

In 2019, New York did raise the age of criminal responsibility to 18. But that change did not move every 17-year-old out of adult court. If you are 17 and charged with a misdemeanor, your case goes to Family Court. But if you are charged with a felony, you are called an Adolescent Offender — and your case starts in adult court, in the Youth Part of Supreme Court, where Family Court judges preside.

The case starts in adult court — and the law presumes it should move.

The presumption is that an Adolescent Offender's case should be transferred to Family Court. For a non-violent felony, the District Attorney has to move within 30 days and show extraordinary circumstances to keep it in adult court. For a violent felony, the case stays in the Youth Part unless the DA consents to removal if the People prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, one of three things: that someone was seriously hurt, that a gun or deadly weapon was displayed, or that it was a sex offense (CPL § 722.23(2)(c)).

Why this case stayed in Supreme Court.

In this case, Javits Frimpong was shot and killed, and a gun was used — two of the three factors. So the judge kept the case in Supreme Court, and the 17-year-old now faces murder, manslaughter, and weapons charges as an adult.

Even in Youth Part, the stakes are adult.

Being in the Youth Part does not mean the case is a juvenile case. If he is convicted and the judge denies him Youthful Offender status, that is an adult conviction — a permanent criminal record. Youthful Offender status (CPL Article 720) is discretionary, not automatic, and a case that is transferred to Family Court is the only path that ends with no criminal conviction at all.

One thing to keep straight.

The 17-year-old is charged, not convicted. He is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty, and the facts above are what prosecutors allege. The trial — if the case gets there — will decide what actually happened.

Raise the Age did not end adult prosecution for 17-year-olds — or 16-year-olds. It just made the court ask first whether the case belongs in Family Court. And for a murder with a gun, the answer was no.

Know Your Rights · Raise the Age · Juvenile Justice · Criminal Defense · Bronx

This post is general information only, not legal advice. Attorney Advertising. Every case is different; if you need advice about your situation, contact a lawyer.

Contact the Firm

Consultations are arranged through the Contact page, which sends an email directly to the firm.


LOGO2 copy.png

Thirty-Nine Twenty-Five Wilder Avenue | Bronx, New York 10466 | 212.271.3046

Copyright 2016-2023 | CARRION LAW GROUP, P.C. | All rights reserved | Attorney Advertising | Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome

Disclaimer | FAQ | Pay Your Bill